Fantastic thread, magdalene! Makes me want to go to all the POL five-star destinations! Here's my entry:
http://www.frommers.com/destinations/montreal/D52113.html
I'm willing to bet there are more good restaurants in Montreal proportional to the total number of restaurants than in any other city--it's certainly true of any city I've been in. In Montreal it's hard to find a bad meal from the most haute-cuisine toney restaurant to the neighbourhood greasy spoon.
But my favourite restaurant is
L'Express, a little bit of Paris in Montreal. When you walk in it's almost always crowded, even at 1am! Better to make a reservation unless it's between mealtimes. The food is resolutely French bistro and the atmosphere is like a mini trip to France. Year after year this restaurant has delivered consistent menus, good service, quality and atmosphere.
Oh, and puh-leez get the
Īle flottante (floating island) for dessert! Here's an approximation but in pages and pages on Google I couldn't find a pic showing the grandeur of the one from
L'Express!